At the risk of sounding like a neanderthal…
…I have a question. Is there a Biblical basis for objecting to a woman serving as president?
I don’t know the answer, but I’d like to.
For any of my readers who are interested in commenting on this topic, please read both this post and the links I’ve included, and then weigh in with your two cents worth.
If you’ve read my previous posts, you know that I support Sarah Palin’s nomination. I also think that some women may be more capable leaders than some men. I do not think that women are in any way inferior to men. None of those statements, however, have anything to do with my original question.
The Bible makes it clear, I think, that in the church a woman is not to govern a man. “I do not permit a woman to teach or to exercise authority over a man; rather, she is to remain quiet. For Adam was formed first, then Eve; and Adam was not deceived, but the woman was deceived and became a transgressor.” (1 Timothy 2:12-14)
I realize that’s a controversial passage, but there’s no sense pretending it isn’t there. Paul bases his argument both on the order of creation, and on the order of transgression at The Fall. He does something similar in 1 Corinthians 11 when he bases his argument there on the order of creation (v.8), and the distinct role for which women were created (v.9).
Taken together, those passages seem to teach that the order and the purpose and the events of both Creation and The Fall demonstrate that a woman should not exercise authority over a man.
So, if you believe that a woman should not exercise authority over a man in the church, should that principle be extended to all other spheres of life?
Please read this post at The Eschatablogical Intrusion and my interaction with the author in the comments, and this post at Reformed Baptist Fellowship.
Then, comment to your heart’s content. Thanks.








After gaining my wifes’ permission, I offer the following observation (jus’ kiddin’)
In Biblical times there were powerful women in leadership roles. This was true for Jesus’ time as well. The fact that He did not teach this to be against the Fathers will leads me to believe that there is nothing theologically wrong with women in public leadership.
JL
Hey, John. Glad your wife gave you permission to comment!
I’ve always had the same opinion you just expressed, and I like Palin as a VP candidate.
I had never really thought much about the role of women in government until I ran across a couple of other articles this weekend. Did you happen to read the last article I linked to over at Reformed Baptist Fellowship? Do you have any thoughts about it?
It’s an excerpt from a new book which I’ll probably try to read at some point, because it sounds interesting. His thesis in that brief excerpt seems to be that female leadership in Scripture is a concession based on male dereliction, and therefore an exception.
Also, what do you make of Paul’s arguments in 1 Cor. 11 and 1 Tim. 2? Does the fact that he bases his argument on the order of creation in both passages imply that it should have universal application to all spheres of life?
I think the Two Kingdoms doctrine clears up this problem. You can find posts about this teaching here My Two Kingdoms Bookmarks on Delicious
The way I understand it, the order of Creation is for the church… and, of course, the family. I have only studied this doctrine for about a year, so I’m not sure I can explain it. But, the posts I link to are good and also check out Issues, Etc. podcast You can also subscribe in iTunes. They recently had an episode on the order of Creation. And, they often address the Two Kingdoms doctrine.
If women should not hold public office, I’m pretty sure you would have to extend that to the workplace, also. And, with that never have a women ever in authority over a man. I do not think that is scriptural. I would suspect that Lydia, the Christian seller of purple, had some men working for her.
P. S. I am very excited about Palin as VP. I’d like to switch the ticket around.
Perhaps this will give her a good leg up on the national scene.
Hi, Renee. Thanks for your comments. I’ll check out those del.icio.us tags!